Press "Enter" to skip to content

Be Skeptical of New Meds

I prescribe heartburn medicines every day. There’s a gaggle of them now — Prilosec, Nexium, Prevacid, Protonix — to name a few. As far as experts know, their primary effect is to reduce the production of stomach acid. This is why they are so effective at putting out your heartburn fire. In simple terms: no acid, no heartburn.

I am quite sure that well-meaning physicians like myself do not understand or will ever know all of the unintended effects of tampering with a digestive process that took a few million years or so to evolve. Are we so arrogant that we believe that these drugs only target gastric acid production?

They are absorbed into the bloodstream and course through every organ of the body. Is it not conceivable that certain tissues might be sensitive to these foreign invaders? Might there be unintended consequences that occur far downstream well beyond our horizon similar to a butterfly effect? Do we think that gastric acid is present to bother us and it serves no useful function?

The human body is a supremely elegant, complex, and integrated structure. Tampering with one part of it may have wildly indirect consequences so far removed that we will not recognize the connection. Consider these examples:

  • A certain class of antibiotics can cause rupture of the Achilles’ tendon
  • An anti-malarial medicine can cause nightmares
  • Rotavirus vaccine can cause intestinal blockage

There is science underlying the three examples above, but consider how implausible the causal connections between the drugs and the side-effects are?

Imagine what we don’t know.

This is why seasoned medical professionals prescribe new medicines sparingly. A new vanguard of medicines has entered the arena. Biologic drugs have stormed into the medical universe promising to stem the progression of many stubborn diseases such as Crohn’s disease, rheumatoid arthritis, psoriasis, and ulcerative colitis. We have all seen commercials for these agents on television, where the actors posing as patients are always fit and often engaged in some athletic activity. These medicines, which tamper with the immune system by design, must be taken forever. The list of potential known side effects covers several pages in small print and range from life-threatening infections to cancer. And, to repeat a line from this very post, imagine what we don’t know.

The human body is a masterpiece of design and function. When we pull on a thread, we may be distorting the far corners of the tapestry and never even realize that we were the culprit.

My advice to my colleagues and my patients? Be skeptical and humble always.

Michael Kirsch, MD, is a gastroenterologist who blogs at MD Whistleblower. This post originally appeared on KevinMD.


last updated